promoting care, opposing euthanasia

twitter facebook youtube rss rss

a sober warning of the dangers of legalising assisted suicide

more: Articles, Abroad, Articles/Abroad

13th June 2011

a sober warning of the dangers of legalising assisted suicide

Kevorkian’s life and death
Jack Kevorkian, the American pathologist known by many as 'Dr Death' for his role in helping over 100 people commit suicide, died early last Friday morning in Detroit.

Kevorkian's lawyer, Mayer Morganroth, told the Detroit Free Press that the infamous euthanasiast appears to have suffered a pulmonary thrombosis after a blood clot in his leg broke free and became lodged in his heart.

Kevorkian, who killed or assisted in the death of about 130 people, was released in 2007 after eight years for the second-degree murder of Thomas Youk. He had given Youk the lethal injection himself, and, in a videotape of Youk's death, dared authorities to try to convict him. He sent a copy to CBS's 60 Minutes in 1998. Critics called it a snuff film and the judge overseeing the case accused Kevorkian of arrogance and disrespect for society.

He was released early from a 10-25 year sentence amidst claims of extremely poor health and that he had only a year to live. Once out of jail, however, he continued his campaign for assisted suicide with high-profile speeches, for which he commanded considerable speaking fees. For a 2007 speech at Florida University he was reportedly paid $50,000.

The euthanasia lobby attempted to redefine Kevorkian's image in recent years. In particular, Kevorkian was the subject of favourable biopic last year starring Al Pacino called 'You Don't Know Jack'.

But, despite claims that his murders were motivated by compassion, Kevorkian once described the alleviation of his victims' suffering as 'a first step, an early distasteful professional obligation' to get a license for human experimentation. He was open about his desire to obtain organs for transplantation and experimentation. He even took the kidneys of one victim to a 1998 press conference where he offered them 'first come, first served'.

He criticized assisted suicide laws in states like Oregon and Montana for restricting the deadly practice to patients who are terminally ill. About 70% of his victims were merely disabled and five were found to be healthy after autopsies were performed.

Kevorkian's antics alienated people and fueled intense criticism. He dropped bodies off at hospitals and dumped them in parks and abandoned buildings.

The American Medical Association in 1995 urged Michigan's attorney general to put a stop to Kevorkian, calling him 'a reckless instrument of death' who 'poses a great threat to the public.'

He was charged with murder four times, only to have three juries acquit him and one case collapse in mistrial (for more details on his life see Mercator Net)

Kevorkian's campaign to legalize doctor-assisted suicide has had limited success. While his native Michigan rejected a proposal shortly before he went to trial, the state of Oregon passed the Death With Dignity Act in 1997 and the state of Washington followed suit in 2008.

Some 525 patients in Oregon and 135 in Washington have died after ingesting lethal doses of medication prescribed by their doctors since the laws were enacted, state records show.

Yet doctor-assisted suicide emerged as the most controversial cultural issue in Gallup's 2011 values and beliefs poll which was released last week, with Americans divided 45 percent (down from 51% in 2008) versus 48 percent over whether it is morally acceptable or morally wrong.

The increasing public perception that assisted suicide is immoral comes in the wake of parliamentary decisions in six countries in the last 18 months to block any change in the law to allow it. Kevorkian's passing is a further reminder of the dangers of decriminalization.

The British 1961 Suicide Act continues to provide a strong deterrent to the exploitation and abuse of elderly and disabled people.

On the basis of the 2005 House of Lords Select Committee Report an Oregon-type law in Britain, as proposed by Dignity in Dying (formerly the Voluntary Euthanasia Society), would lead to about 1,000 assisted suicide deaths in this country each year.

This is in stark contrast to the relatively small number of British residents (160 over ten years) who have travelled to the Dignitas facility in Switzerland to end their lives.

more Abroad

comments

there are no comments at this time.
Please enable javascript to post comments!